Difference between revisions of "Virechana (विरेचनम्)"

From Dharmawiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Editing the content)
Line 17: Line 17:
  
 
== Etymology ==
 
== Etymology ==
Prushta 4918 (Vachaspatyam)
+
In Vachaspatyam, etiology of the word virechanam can be found. <blockquote>वि + रिच--णिच्--ल्युट् । मलादेर्निःसारणे <ref>Vachaspatyam ([https://sa.wikisource.org/wiki/%E0%A4%B5%E0%A4%BE%E0%A4%9A%E0%A4%B8%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%AA%E0%A4%A4%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%AF%E0%A4%AE%E0%A5%8D/%E0%A4%B5%E0%A4%BF%E0%A4%9C%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%9E%E0%A4%BE%E0%A4%A8 Pag 4918])</ref></blockquote>According to this etyology, the word Virechana is derived from the root 'ric' which means to expel. The term virechanam can be spit into 3 parts as below,
  
<nowiki>https://sa.wikisource.org/wiki/%E0%A4%B5%E0%A4%BE%E0%A4%9A%E0%A4%B8%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%AA%E0%A4%A4%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%AF%E0%A4%AE%E0%A5%8D/%E0%A4%B5%E0%A4%BF%E0%A4%9C%E0%A5%8D%E0%A4%9E%E0%A4%BE%E0%A4%A8</nowiki>
+
Vi – upasarga (prefix)
  
 +
ric- dhatu (root)
  
वि + रिच--णिच्--ल्युट् । मलादेर्निःसारणे
+
Lyut- pratyaya (suffix)
  
The word Virechana is derived from
+
Meaning- to expel or evacuate the mala (impurity).
  
Vi – upasarga(prefix), ric- dhatu(root), Lyut- pratyaya(suffix)
+
Thus, expulsion of morbid doshas or malas (impurities) of body is known as virechanam. In Ayurveda this term specifically indicates such expulsion through anal route by purgation which is done in a controlled manner as a theraputic procedure.
  
Meaning- to expel or evacuate the mala(impurity).
+
== Indications for Virechana Karma ==
 +
Before advising the patient for virechana karma, physician considers whether the patient is fit or unfit for virechana procedure.
  
Thus, expulsion of morbid doshas, mala(impurities) through anal route is virechana.
+
Indications for any panchakarma are mainly based on the dominance of dosha in a particular disorder and the site at which dosha provokes.  Thus, to mention few, indications for virechana karma are,
  
== Fit and Unfit for virechana ==
 
WHO ARE FIT FOR VIRECHANA KARMA(INDICATIONS)
 
  
Gulma (swelling in abdomen)
 
  
Arshas (piles/haemorrhoids)
+
* Gulma (swelling in abdomen)
 +
* Arshas (piles/haemorrhoids)
 +
* Visphota (skin eruptions)
 +
* Kamala (jaundice)
 +
* Jeerna Jwara (chronic fever)
 +
* Vidradhi (abscess)
 +
* Timira (eye condition)
 +
* Krimi (worm infestations)
 +
* Vrana (wounds and ulcers)
 +
* Pakvashaya vyatha (intestinal conditions)
 +
* Vatarakta (gout)
 +
* Apasmara (epilepsy)
 +
* Yoni dosha (reproductive diseases) etc. <ref name=":0">Charaka Samhita (Siddhisthanam Adhayaya 2 Sutra 11-13)</ref> <ref name=":1">Ashtanga Hrudayam (Sutrasthanam Adhyaya 27 Sutras 8-9)</ref> <ref name=":2">Sushruta Samhita (Chikitsasthanam Adhyaya 33 Sutra 25-32)</ref>
  
Visphota (skin eruptions)
+
== Contraindications for Virechana Karma ==
 +
Virechana is not advised in Kapha dosha predominant diseases. In such cases virechana may not be carried out successfully due to excess kapha dosha hampering the action of virechaka dravyas (Purgative drugs). Inappropriately conducted virechana then can lead to complications. Also in individuals who have very weak digestive strength (agni) and overall strength (Balam), virechana is not recommended.
  
Kamala (jaundice)
 
  
Jeerna Jwara (chronic fever)
 
  
Vidradhi (abscess)
+
There are certain conditions listed in the classical treatises wherein Virechana karma is not advised by Ayurveda acharyas,
  
Timira (eye condition)
+
* Alpa agni (weak digestive fire)
 
+
* Adhoga raktapitta (bleeding disorders through lower orifices)
Krimi (worm infestations)
+
* Kshatakshina (emaciation)
 
+
* Atisaara (diarrhoea)
Vrana (wounds and ulcers)
+
* Baala (infant)
 
+
* Kshama (weak)
Pakvashaya vyatha (intestinal conditions)
+
* Garbhini(pregnant)
 
+
* Abhighata (injury)
Vatarakta (gout)
+
* Durbala(weak)
 
+
* Madatyaya(alcoholic)
Apasmara (epilepsy)
+
* Durbala indriya(weak sensory organs) etc  <ref name=":0" /> <ref name=":1" /> <ref name=":2" />
 
 
Yoni dosha (reproductive diseases)
 
 
 
And many more (char.sidd.2.11-13) (asht.sutr.27.8-9) (sush. Chik. 33.25)
 
 
 
 
 
WHO ARE UNFIT FOR VIRECHANA KARMA(CONTRAINDICATIONS)
 
 
 
There are certain conditions listed in the classical treatises wherein Virechana karma is not advised,
 
 
 
Alpa agni(weak digestive fire)
 
 
 
Adhoga raktapitta (bleeding disorders through lower orifices)
 
 
 
Kshatakshina (emaciation)
 
 
 
Atisaara (diarrhoea)
 
 
 
Baala (infant)
 
 
 
Kshama (weak)
 
 
 
Garbhini(pregnant)
 
 
 
Abhighata (injury)
 
 
 
Durbala(weak)
 
 
 
Madatyaya(alcoholic)
 
 
 
Durbala indriya(weak sensory organs)
 
 
 
And few others (char.sidd.2.11-13) (asht.sutr.27.8-9) (sush. Chik. 33.25-32)
 
  
 
== Procedure ==
 
== Procedure ==
The procedure of virechana karma is divided in 3 sections
+
The procedure of virechana karma is divided in 3 steps
  
PURVA KARMA (PRE-PROCEDURE)
+
# Purva Karma (pre procedure/before procedure)
 
+
# Pradhana Karma (main procedure)
PRADHANA KARMA (MAIN PROCEDURE)
+
# Pashchat Karma (after procedure)
 
 
PASCHAT KARMA (AFTER PROCEDURE)
 
  
 
=== Purva karma ===
 
=== Purva karma ===
 
Before assigning the patient for Virechana karma it is essential to decide whether the individual is fit for virechana karma. If condition of patient is not appropriately checked there are high chances of complications.
 
Before assigning the patient for Virechana karma it is essential to decide whether the individual is fit for virechana karma. If condition of patient is not appropriately checked there are high chances of complications.
  
Purva karma includes the process which involves everything which is to be done before the actual virechana karma,
+
Purva karma (Purva- pre, Karma-procedure) includes the process which involves everything which is to be done before the actual virechana karma,
 
 
Collection of materials- this includes all the essential material, equipment’s, medicines to induces purgation or to manage complications ready beforehand. Few medicines and oil for abhyanga might be asked by your Vaidya to bring from store.
 
 
 
Assessment of patient – patient or individual will be assessed by various parameters like, Dashavidha pareeksha or 10-fold examination which includes prakruti of patient and many other aspects. Ashtavidha pareeksha or 8-fold examination which includes naadi(pulse), bowel, bladder movements etc. This assessment is essential to know the strength of the patient and dose fixation. Patient’s blood pressure, pulse and various systemic examination will also be carried out when necessary. Basic biochemical test is done if necessary.
 
 
 
Deepana and pachana karma – this is one the important pre procedure which involves kindling of digestive fire and enhancing the metabolism. Deepana and pachana dravya(drugs) are administered orally before virechana karma to prepare the body for digestion of heavy quantities of ghrita, Virechana medicine etc which will be decided by the Vaidya.
 
 
 
Snehapana vidhi – snehapana or administration of medicated ghee is essential before virechana karma. For a period of 3-7 days in the morning, medicated ghee is administered orally in increasing pattern until Vaidya decides. The dose and period are decided based on the digestive ability of individual.
 
 
 
Abhyanga and swedana – Abhyanga with medicated oil is done followed by swedana(fomentation or full body steam) after snehapana until the day of virechana, which is upto 3 days.
 
 
 
Ahara – dietic regimen during the snepana is strictly followed to ease the process the virechana. Virechana required high pitta dosha in body, thus during snehapana patient is advised to consume food, which is liquidy in natue and hot in potency, it should not be too unctuous. A day before virechana karma patient is advisd to take laghu(light), ushna(hot), drava(liquidy), snigdha (unctuous), phalaamla rasa (juice of sour fruits) etc. during this whole process patient is advised to take lukewarm water whole time. (sush.chik.31.20) (asht.sutr.16.24)
 
  
Matra nirnaya(dose fixation) – dosage of virechana dravya is decided based on parameters like agni(digestive fire), roga bala(strength of disease), rogi bala(strength of patient), form of administration like churna(powder), kvatha(decoction), etc(char.sutr.15.10)
+
# '''Collection of materials'''- This includes keeping all the essential material, equipments, medicines to induce purgation or to manage complications ready beforehand. Few medicines and oil for [[Abhyanga (अभ्यङ्गम् )|abhyanga]] might be asked by your Vaidya to be brought from store.
 +
# '''Assessment of patient''' – Patient or individual will be assessed on the basis of various parameters like, Dashavidha pareeksha or 10-fold examination which includes assessment of [[Prakrti in Ayurveda (प्रकृतिः)|prakrti]] of patient, aggrvated doshas, balam (strength), Kala (time of the year and climate), age and many other aspects. Ashtavidha pareeksha or 8-fold examination which includes nadi (pulse), bowel, bladder movements etc. This assessment is essential to know the strength of the patient and dose fixation. Virechana is not given to patients aged below 16 and above 70 years of age. Patient’s blood pressure, pulse and various systemic examination will also be carried out when necessary. Basic biochemical test is done if necessary.
 +
# '''Deepana and pachana karma''' – This is one the important pre procedure which involves kindling of digestive fire and enhancing the metabolism through medicines before posting the patient for virechanam and starting the snehapanam (oral administration of medicated ghee or oil). Deepana and pachana dravyas (drugs) are administered orally before virechana karma to prepare the body for digestion of heavy quantities of ghrita, Virechana medicine etc which will be decided by the [[Vaidya (वैद्यः)|Vaidya]].
 +
# '''Snehapanam''' – Snehapana (Sneha- an unctous substance like ghee or oil, pana-to drink) or administration of medicated ghee is essential before virechana karma. For a period of 3-7 days in the morning, medicated ghee is administered orally in escalating pattern until Vaidya decides to stop on the basis of signs and symptoms of oleation (snehanam) in the patient's body. The dose and period are decided based on the digestive ability of individual and signs of proper oleation (Snehanam) in the body. Appropriately done snehapanam is crucial for proper conduction of virechanam.
 +
# '''Abhyanga and swedanam''' – [[Abhyanga (अभ्यङ्गम् )|Abhyanga]] with medicated oil is done followed by swedana (sudation or fomentation or full body steam bath) after completion of snehapana until the day of virechana,. Usually there is gap of 2-3 days between completion of snehapanam and the day of actual virechana karma and in this gap abhyanagm and swedanam is done
 +
# '''Diet before virechanam karma'''– Dietic regimen during the snepana is strictly followed to ease the process the virechana. Virechanam required high pitta dosha in body, thus after snehapana patient is advised to consume food, which is liquidy in nature and hot in potency, it should not be too unctuous. A day before virechana karma patient is advised to take laghu (light), ushna (hot), drava (liquidy), snigdha (unctuous), phalaamla rasa (juice of sour fruits) etc.
 +
# '''Water''' -Dduring this entire process of  virechanam, the patient is advised to take lukewarm water whole time.<ref>Sushruta Samhita (chikitsasthanam Adhyaya 31 Sutra 20)</ref> <ref>Ashtanga Hrudayam (Sutrasthanam Adhyaya 16 Sutra 24)</ref>
 +
# '''Matra nirnaya (dose fixation''') – The dosage of virechana dravya is decided based on parameters like agni (digestive fire), roga balam (severity of disease), rogi [[Balam (बलम्)|balam]] (strength of patient), formulation of drug like churna (powder), kvatha (decoction), etc<ref>Charaka Samhita (Sutrasthanam Adhyaya 15 Sutra 10)</ref>
  
 
Individual or patient is well acknowledged about the procedure beforehand. To keep the patient in good mental health, patient is required to have a good sleep, overhead bath, worn clean clothes, worshiping deities. Thus, a positive, happy and calm atmosphere is necessary.
 
Individual or patient is well acknowledged about the procedure beforehand. To keep the patient in good mental health, patient is required to have a good sleep, overhead bath, worn clean clothes, worshiping deities. Thus, a positive, happy and calm atmosphere is necessary.

Revision as of 16:43, 27 December 2021

ToBeEdited.png
This article needs editing.

Add and improvise the content from reliable sources.

Virechana karma is one another Panchakarma therapy where morbid doshas in the body are eliminated through anal route by inducing purgation in a controlled manner. Virechana literally means evacuation, excretion or purgation. It is a prime method in the treatment of morbid pitta dosha and its related disorders. Virechana karma is most commonly and widely known as one of the detoxification processes. In few traditional Indian houses, purgation is followed in the sharada rtu or lunar calender months of ashvin and karthika masas (mid-august to mid-october) with a minimum quantity of castor oil. But only the purgation and not the whole process of virechana is followed. Although, this must and should be done under the supervision and advise of Vaidya or concerned physician trained in conducting Panchakarmas.

Basti karma, which is another Panchkarma therapy also expels the morbid doshas through anal route, but the procedure and the drug administration are very dissimilar. The drug is administered through anal route in basti while it is administered though oral route in virechana.

Definition

Virechana karma is defined as below,

तत्र दोषहरणमूर्ध्वभागं वमनसञ्ज्ञकम्, अधोभागं विरेचनसञ्ज्ञकम्; उभयं वा शरीरमलविरेचनाद्विरेचनसञ्ज्ञां लभते (Char. Samh. 1.4)[1]

Meaning: The procedure in which the morbid doshas are expelled out from body through mouth is called as vamanam, Iwhere these doshas are expelled out via) anal route by (controlled and therapeutic) purgation is called as virechana karma. Since by any route the morbid doshas in body are eliminated or evacuated both of these karmas can be called as virechana.

However virechana refers to theraputic purgation as a general rule.

According to Sharangdhar Samhita (purv. khan.4.25) virechana karma is  a process wherein the virechaka dravyas (purgative drugs) expel the digested or undigested food particles through anal route.[2]

Etymology

In Vachaspatyam, etiology of the word virechanam can be found.

वि + रिच--णिच्--ल्युट् । मलादेर्निःसारणे [3]

According to this etyology, the word Virechana is derived from the root 'ric' which means to expel. The term virechanam can be spit into 3 parts as below,

Vi – upasarga (prefix)

ric- dhatu (root)

Lyut- pratyaya (suffix)

Meaning- to expel or evacuate the mala (impurity).

Thus, expulsion of morbid doshas or malas (impurities) of body is known as virechanam. In Ayurveda this term specifically indicates such expulsion through anal route by purgation which is done in a controlled manner as a theraputic procedure.

Indications for Virechana Karma

Before advising the patient for virechana karma, physician considers whether the patient is fit or unfit for virechana procedure.

Indications for any panchakarma are mainly based on the dominance of dosha in a particular disorder and the site at which dosha provokes.  Thus, to mention few, indications for virechana karma are,


  • Gulma (swelling in abdomen)
  • Arshas (piles/haemorrhoids)
  • Visphota (skin eruptions)
  • Kamala (jaundice)
  • Jeerna Jwara (chronic fever)
  • Vidradhi (abscess)
  • Timira (eye condition)
  • Krimi (worm infestations)
  • Vrana (wounds and ulcers)
  • Pakvashaya vyatha (intestinal conditions)
  • Vatarakta (gout)
  • Apasmara (epilepsy)
  • Yoni dosha (reproductive diseases) etc. [4] [5] [6]

Contraindications for Virechana Karma

Virechana is not advised in Kapha dosha predominant diseases. In such cases virechana may not be carried out successfully due to excess kapha dosha hampering the action of virechaka dravyas (Purgative drugs). Inappropriately conducted virechana then can lead to complications. Also in individuals who have very weak digestive strength (agni) and overall strength (Balam), virechana is not recommended.


There are certain conditions listed in the classical treatises wherein Virechana karma is not advised by Ayurveda acharyas,

  • Alpa agni (weak digestive fire)
  • Adhoga raktapitta (bleeding disorders through lower orifices)
  • Kshatakshina (emaciation)
  • Atisaara (diarrhoea)
  • Baala (infant)
  • Kshama (weak)
  • Garbhini(pregnant)
  • Abhighata (injury)
  • Durbala(weak)
  • Madatyaya(alcoholic)
  • Durbala indriya(weak sensory organs) etc [4] [5] [6]

Procedure

The procedure of virechana karma is divided in 3 steps

  1. Purva Karma (pre procedure/before procedure)
  2. Pradhana Karma (main procedure)
  3. Pashchat Karma (after procedure)

Purva karma

Before assigning the patient for Virechana karma it is essential to decide whether the individual is fit for virechana karma. If condition of patient is not appropriately checked there are high chances of complications.

Purva karma (Purva- pre, Karma-procedure) includes the process which involves everything which is to be done before the actual virechana karma,

  1. Collection of materials- This includes keeping all the essential material, equipments, medicines to induce purgation or to manage complications ready beforehand. Few medicines and oil for abhyanga might be asked by your Vaidya to be brought from store.
  2. Assessment of patient – Patient or individual will be assessed on the basis of various parameters like, Dashavidha pareeksha or 10-fold examination which includes assessment of prakrti of patient, aggrvated doshas, balam (strength), Kala (time of the year and climate), age and many other aspects. Ashtavidha pareeksha or 8-fold examination which includes nadi (pulse), bowel, bladder movements etc. This assessment is essential to know the strength of the patient and dose fixation. Virechana is not given to patients aged below 16 and above 70 years of age. Patient’s blood pressure, pulse and various systemic examination will also be carried out when necessary. Basic biochemical test is done if necessary.
  3. Deepana and pachana karma – This is one the important pre procedure which involves kindling of digestive fire and enhancing the metabolism through medicines before posting the patient for virechanam and starting the snehapanam (oral administration of medicated ghee or oil). Deepana and pachana dravyas (drugs) are administered orally before virechana karma to prepare the body for digestion of heavy quantities of ghrita, Virechana medicine etc which will be decided by the Vaidya.
  4. Snehapanam – Snehapana (Sneha- an unctous substance like ghee or oil, pana-to drink) or administration of medicated ghee is essential before virechana karma. For a period of 3-7 days in the morning, medicated ghee is administered orally in escalating pattern until Vaidya decides to stop on the basis of signs and symptoms of oleation (snehanam) in the patient's body. The dose and period are decided based on the digestive ability of individual and signs of proper oleation (Snehanam) in the body. Appropriately done snehapanam is crucial for proper conduction of virechanam.
  5. Abhyanga and swedanamAbhyanga with medicated oil is done followed by swedana (sudation or fomentation or full body steam bath) after completion of snehapana until the day of virechana,. Usually there is gap of 2-3 days between completion of snehapanam and the day of actual virechana karma and in this gap abhyanagm and swedanam is done
  6. Diet before virechanam karma– Dietic regimen during the snepana is strictly followed to ease the process the virechana. Virechanam required high pitta dosha in body, thus after snehapana patient is advised to consume food, which is liquidy in nature and hot in potency, it should not be too unctuous. A day before virechana karma patient is advised to take laghu (light), ushna (hot), drava (liquidy), snigdha (unctuous), phalaamla rasa (juice of sour fruits) etc.
  7. Water -Dduring this entire process of virechanam, the patient is advised to take lukewarm water whole time.[7] [8]
  8. Matra nirnaya (dose fixation) – The dosage of virechana dravya is decided based on parameters like agni (digestive fire), roga balam (severity of disease), rogi balam (strength of patient), formulation of drug like churna (powder), kvatha (decoction), etc[9]

Individual or patient is well acknowledged about the procedure beforehand. To keep the patient in good mental health, patient is required to have a good sleep, overhead bath, worn clean clothes, worshiping deities. Thus, a positive, happy and calm atmosphere is necessary.

Pradhana Karma

Administration of virechana dravya- It is essential to administer drug or dravya after kapha kala has passed, thus the dravya should be given around 9am till 11 am in the morning on empty stomach.

Observation and advises – patient must gargle with hot water to avoid initial nausea due to drug.  Patient is advised to take rest, not get exposed to cold winds or air conditioners. Hot water is given at repeated intervals for easy and unhindered vega(bouts) of purgation.  The vega(bouts) of virechana take time to start compared to vamana vega(bout), thus patient must wait and be attentive. Patient is told to observe colour, quantity, odour, sound etc of the each vega and inform to Vaidya.

The purification might occur in varying number of vega(bout) which are influenced by few factors like age, strength of patient, strength of disease etc.

There are certain features stated by acharyas to assess whether the procedure has been done appropriately and if the doshas have been eradicated completely indicating samyak yoga (appropriate), ayoga (insufficient elimination) and atiyoga (excess elimination). Kaphanta virechana is the samyak lakshana (appropriate symptom) of virechana karma, which precisely means that when there is mucous like substance is seen the virechana bouts is stopped.

Further patient is assessed for any kind of complications like, Adhmana (Distension of abdomen), parikartika (cutting like pain in anal region), hridgraha  (cardiac spasms or ache), sraava (excessive discharge of any kind), jivadana(blood discharge), graha (rigidity and spasms) etc. these complications can arise if the vamana karma is done inappropriately. Further treatment is given immediately in any such case. (char. sidd.6.29).

Pashchata Karma

After vega(bouts) of purgation are stopped, paschat karma begins.

Paschat karma remains same as that of vamana karma. Which are dhumapana (therapeutic smoke), rest, dietic regimen, and few lifestyles advises and restrictions.

Mode of action

Virechana karma can be closely related to inducing laxation, purgation, evacuants in modern texts. Laxatives induce mild inflammation in the lower bowel to promote water and electrolyte accumulation and stimulation of intestinal motility. From this view, virechana dravya are mild irritant to stomach and intestinal mucosa to cause inflammation. Thus, permeability of the membrane changes. This mechanism allows quick initial absorption of virechana dravya and later leads to excretion of morbid substances due to the active principal present in the drug. Precisely, virechana karma is a whole systemic cleansing procedure rather than induced purgation. The advantages are wide spread and not organ specific.

Other therapeutic considerations

After the intake of virechana dravya vega initiation will take around 60 to 120 mins. Since virechana yoga or medicine needs to be digested before the bouts start. This mechanism depends on the digestive ability of the individual and dose of the medicine which are decided by a Vaidya.

In some conditions of bahu kapha (excessive kapha dosha), bouts of purgation start in the evening after the liquefication of kapha dosha. Patient is kept under observation in such conditions. (char.kalpa.12)

Virechana medicine is given again on the same day if there are no vega(bouts) or dosha elimination seen. This is decided by the Vaidya. (char. Kalp. 12.63)

Patient must acknowlwdge vaidya about number, colour, sound, texture and the gap between the vega(bouts) as well.

in few cases vamana(vomiting) occurs after the intake of virechana medicine due to initial nausea. In such conditions Vaidya asks patient to wash mouth clean and fasting is done on that day and virechana karma is conducted again on the next day. (char.kalp.12.67)

Virechana karma is carried out prophylactically in sharad rutu of hindu calender which is mid-august till mid- September under the supervision of a Vaidya. Virechana being the front line shodhana treatment in pitta dosha related disorders and pitta dosha is elevated during sharad rutu the process is at ease and prevents seasonal diseases.

References

  1. Charaka Samhita (Kalpasthanam Adhyaya 1 Sutram 4)
  2. Sharangadhara Samhita (Purvakhandam Adhyaya 4 Sutram 25)
  3. Vachaspatyam (Pag 4918)
  4. 4.0 4.1 Charaka Samhita (Siddhisthanam Adhayaya 2 Sutra 11-13)
  5. 5.0 5.1 Ashtanga Hrudayam (Sutrasthanam Adhyaya 27 Sutras 8-9)
  6. 6.0 6.1 Sushruta Samhita (Chikitsasthanam Adhyaya 33 Sutra 25-32)
  7. Sushruta Samhita (chikitsasthanam Adhyaya 31 Sutra 20)
  8. Ashtanga Hrudayam (Sutrasthanam Adhyaya 16 Sutra 24)
  9. Charaka Samhita (Sutrasthanam Adhyaya 15 Sutra 10)