Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
added video
Line 1: Line 1:  +
[[File:Shad darshanas flowchart.PNG|thumb|400x400px|The Six Astika Darshanas]]
 
The Six Darsanas  or Shad Darshanas (Samskrit : षड्दर्शनानि) include the intellectual and theological discussions of concepts found in Bharatiya siddhantas (सिद्धान्तः । theory). Bharatiya darshana granthas have been intensely emphatic on practical realization of truth as against the Western Philosophy which is essentially an intellectual quest for truth.<ref name=":22" />     
 
The Six Darsanas  or Shad Darshanas (Samskrit : षड्दर्शनानि) include the intellectual and theological discussions of concepts found in Bharatiya siddhantas (सिद्धान्तः । theory). Bharatiya darshana granthas have been intensely emphatic on practical realization of truth as against the Western Philosophy which is essentially an intellectual quest for truth.<ref name=":22" />     
 +
{{#evu:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p-H0X6ZGXRw&feature=youtu.be
 +
|alignment=right
 +
|dimensions=500x248
 +
|container=frame
 +
|description=Talk on Indian Philosophical Systems: A Synthetic Appreciation
 +
}}
 
== व्युत्पत्तिः || Etymology ==
 
== व्युत्पत्तिः || Etymology ==
   Line 57: Line 64:  
* Nastika (नास्तिकः)
 
* Nastika (नास्तिकः)
 
The term ''Astika'' comes from the Samskrit word Asti (अस्ति । there is) is defined as one that accepts the authority of the Vedas (sacred scriptures of ancient India). The ''Nastika'' (न अस्ति । it is not) views are those which neither regard the Vedas as infallible nor try to establish their own validity on their authority.     
 
The term ''Astika'' comes from the Samskrit word Asti (अस्ति । there is) is defined as one that accepts the authority of the Vedas (sacred scriptures of ancient India). The ''Nastika'' (न अस्ति । it is not) views are those which neither regard the Vedas as infallible nor try to establish their own validity on their authority.     
=== अास्तिकदर्शनानि ॥ Astika Darshanas ===
+
=== आस्तिकदर्शनानि ॥ Astika Darshanas ===
 
The term Astika (Samskrit : अास्तिकः) according to Vachaspatyam means अस्ति परलोक इति मतिर्यस्य । one who believes in the existence of paraloka (other worlds). Some schools of philosophy are based on the Vedas all of which proclaim the existence of other lokas (worlds), punarjanma (rebirth), existence of a supreme power etc.<ref name=":12" /><ref name=":02">Swami Sivananda, All About Hinduism, Page 47-51</ref> Six systems of the Indian philosophy called popularly as the Shad Darsanas are the Astika darshanas. They include:
 
The term Astika (Samskrit : अास्तिकः) according to Vachaspatyam means अस्ति परलोक इति मतिर्यस्य । one who believes in the existence of paraloka (other worlds). Some schools of philosophy are based on the Vedas all of which proclaim the existence of other lokas (worlds), punarjanma (rebirth), existence of a supreme power etc.<ref name=":12" /><ref name=":02">Swami Sivananda, All About Hinduism, Page 47-51</ref> Six systems of the Indian philosophy called popularly as the Shad Darsanas are the Astika darshanas. They include:
 
#  न्यायः || [[Nyaya Darshana (न्यायदर्शनम्)|Nyaya]] (Rishi Gautama)
 
#  न्यायः || [[Nyaya Darshana (न्यायदर्शनम्)|Nyaya]] (Rishi Gautama)
Line 64: Line 71:  
#  योगः || Yoga (Maharishi Patanjali)
 
#  योगः || Yoga (Maharishi Patanjali)
 
#  पूर्वमीमांसा || Poorva [[Mimamsa Darsana|Mimamsa]] (Jaimini)
 
#  पूर्वमीमांसा || Poorva [[Mimamsa Darsana|Mimamsa]] (Jaimini)
# उत्तरमीमांसा || Uttara Mimamsa or वेदान्त || [[Vedanta]] (Badarayana or Vyasa) 
+
# उत्तरमीमांसा || Uttara Mimamsa or [[Vedanta (वेदान्तः)|Vedanta]] (Badarayana or Vyasa) 
 
These are often grouped by twos, taken in order, since the are allied to each other. They last pair, (Poorva and Uttara Mimamsa, however, are not so closely akin in their theoretical aspects, according to a few scholars. They are the two schools which are directly based on the Veda. The remaining four schools, in their present form, declare allegiance to the Veda, but it is doubtful whether they were Vedic from the beginning of their history. Astika Darshanas regard the realm of being as by no means exhausted by common experience and acknowledges a unique ''pramana'' for knowing what lies beyond. It may be further divided into two classes <ref name=":32">Hiriyanna. M. (1949) ''The Essentials of Indian Philosophy.'' London : George Allen and Unwin Ltd.</ref>
 
These are often grouped by twos, taken in order, since the are allied to each other. They last pair, (Poorva and Uttara Mimamsa, however, are not so closely akin in their theoretical aspects, according to a few scholars. They are the two schools which are directly based on the Veda. The remaining four schools, in their present form, declare allegiance to the Veda, but it is doubtful whether they were Vedic from the beginning of their history. Astika Darshanas regard the realm of being as by no means exhausted by common experience and acknowledges a unique ''pramana'' for knowing what lies beyond. It may be further divided into two classes <ref name=":32">Hiriyanna. M. (1949) ''The Essentials of Indian Philosophy.'' London : George Allen and Unwin Ltd.</ref>
   Line 103: Line 110:  
The end of man is to get rid of these three kinds of pain and suffering. Liberation means complete cessation of all sufferings which is the highest end of life (Apavarga or Purushardha).<ref name=":22" />
 
The end of man is to get rid of these three kinds of pain and suffering. Liberation means complete cessation of all sufferings which is the highest end of life (Apavarga or Purushardha).<ref name=":22" />
   −
Karma leads us to the endless cycle of Samsara and if we could divest ourselves of all emotions, ideas or desires as lead us to action we should find within us the actionless self which neither suffers nor enjoys, neither works nor undergoes rebirth. Various schools agree in the recognition of liberation or release (moksha) from this cycle of rebirths as the highest of human ends or values. Chaturvarga - Artha, Kama, Dharma and Moksha are the highly revered Purusharthas, or the values. While Artha and Kama which mean wealth and pleasure are purely worldly values, the other two - Dharma and Moksha are described as spiritual. Of them, moksha has come to be acknowledged as the highest of human values by all schools of thought.<ref name=":32" />  
+
Karma leads us to the endless cycle of Samsara and if we could divest ourselves of all emotions, ideas or desires as lead us to action we should find within us the actionless self which neither suffers nor enjoys, neither works nor undergoes rebirth. Various schools agree in the recognition of liberation or release (moksha) from this cycle of rebirths as the highest of human ends or values. Chaturvarga - Artha, Kama, Dharma and Moksha are the highly revered Purusharthas, or the values. While Artha and Kama which mean wealth and pleasure are purely worldly values, the other two - Dharma and Moksha are described as adhyatmik. Of them, moksha has come to be acknowledged as the highest of human values by all schools of thought.<ref name=":32" />  
    
When the Indians, wearied by the endless bustle and turmoil of worldly events, sought for and believed that somewhere a peaceful goal could be found, they generally hit upon the Self of man.  
 
When the Indians, wearied by the endless bustle and turmoil of worldly events, sought for and believed that somewhere a peaceful goal could be found, they generally hit upon the Self of man.  
Line 110: Line 117:     
=== आत्मसिद्धन्तः ॥ Atma Siddhanta ===
 
=== आत्मसिद्धन्तः ॥ Atma Siddhanta ===
All the Indian shastras except Buddhism admit the existence of a permanent entity variously called Atman, Purusha, Jiva (which is being called as Soul, but is not an exact translation of Atma). As to the exact nature of this Atma there are indeed divergences of view.  
+
All the Indian shastras except Buddhism admit the existence of a permanent entity variously called [[Atman (आत्मन्)|Atman]], Purusha, Jiva (which is being called as Soul, but is not an exact translation of Atma). As to the exact nature of this Atma there are indeed divergences of view.  
 
* Nyaya calls it absolutely quantityless and characterless, indeterminate unconscious entity.
 
* Nyaya calls it absolutely quantityless and characterless, indeterminate unconscious entity.
* Samkhya describes it as being of the nature of pure consciousness.
+
* [[Samkhya Darshana (साङ्ख्यदर्शनम्)|Samkhya]] describes it as being of the nature of pure consciousness.
 
* Vedanta says that it is that fundamental point of unity implied in pure consciousness (चित् । chit), pure bliss (आनन्दम् । ananda) and pure being (सत् । sat).  
 
* Vedanta says that it is that fundamental point of unity implied in pure consciousness (चित् । chit), pure bliss (आनन्दम् । ananda) and pure being (सत् । sat).  
 
But all agree in holding that it is pure and unsullied in its nature and that all impurities of action or passion do not form a real part of it. When all impurities are removed the pure nature of the self is thoroughly and permanently apprehended and all other extraneous connections with it are absolutely dissociated.<ref name=":12" />
 
But all agree in holding that it is pure and unsullied in its nature and that all impurities of action or passion do not form a real part of it. When all impurities are removed the pure nature of the self is thoroughly and permanently apprehended and all other extraneous connections with it are absolutely dissociated.<ref name=":12" />
Line 128: Line 135:  
* The Upanishads tell us that the Vedas - the storehouse of knowledge - have been breathed forth from Him (Brhd. Upan. 2.4.10); but they regard the Karma-kanda as secondary, being only a help to purify the mind by which purification one is made fit to receive the real teaching about Brahman.   
 
* The Upanishads tell us that the Vedas - the storehouse of knowledge - have been breathed forth from Him (Brhd. Upan. 2.4.10); but they regard the Karma-kanda as secondary, being only a help to purify the mind by which purification one is made fit to receive the real teaching about Brahman.   
 
* We find in Chandogya Upanishad (7.2) the [[Narada Sanatkumara Samvada (नारदसनत्कुमारयोः संवादः)|Narada Sanatkumara Samvada]] that even though one is well-versed in the knowledge of the Vedas, Mantras and the [[Vaidika Vangmaya (वैदिकवाङ्मयम्)|Chaturdasha Vidyas]], he or she could still be ignorant about the Self. Only one who knows the Self goes beyond sorrow.   
 
* We find in Chandogya Upanishad (7.2) the [[Narada Sanatkumara Samvada (नारदसनत्कुमारयोः संवादः)|Narada Sanatkumara Samvada]] that even though one is well-versed in the knowledge of the Vedas, Mantras and the [[Vaidika Vangmaya (वैदिकवाङ्मयम्)|Chaturdasha Vidyas]], he or she could still be ignorant about the Self. Only one who knows the Self goes beyond sorrow.   
* The Mundakopanishad (1.1.4 and 5) tells us: "Two kinds of knowledge must be known, the higher and the lower. The lower knowledge is that which the Rk, Sama, Atharva, ceremonial, grammar give .... but the higher knowledge is that by which the immortal Brahman is known.     
+
* The Mundakopanishad (1.1.4 and 5) tells us: "Two kinds of knowledge must be known, the higher (Para) and the lower (Apara). The lower knowledge is that which the Rk, Sama, Atharva, ceremonial, grammar give .... but the higher knowledge is that by which the immortal Brahman is known.     
* In the Bhagavadgita (2.45 and 46)also Srikrishna asks Arjuna to rise above the three gunas. <ref name=":22" />   
+
* In the Bhagavadgita (2.45 and 46) also Srikrishna asks Arjuna to rise above the three gunas. <ref name=":22" />   
    
Through the highest moral elevation a man may attain absolute dispassion towards world-experiences and retire in body, mind and speech from all worldly concerns. When the mind is so purified the Self shines in its true light and its true nature is rightly conceived. When this once done the self can never again be associated with passion or ignorance. Self at this stage ultimately dissociates from ''Chitta'', which is the root of all emotions, ideas and actions. Thus, emancipated the self forever conquers all sorrow.<ref name=":12" />
 
Through the highest moral elevation a man may attain absolute dispassion towards world-experiences and retire in body, mind and speech from all worldly concerns. When the mind is so purified the Self shines in its true light and its true nature is rightly conceived. When this once done the self can never again be associated with passion or ignorance. Self at this stage ultimately dissociates from ''Chitta'', which is the root of all emotions, ideas and actions. Thus, emancipated the self forever conquers all sorrow.<ref name=":12" />
Line 136: Line 143:     
=== Nyaya and Vaiseshika ===
 
=== Nyaya and Vaiseshika ===
The Vaiseshika darshana is regarded as conducive to the study of all systems. It deals with the Padarthas (पदार्थः । categories) and the entire universe is reduced to six or seven padarthas. The word 'padartha' means 'the meaning of a word' or 'the object signified by a word'. All objects of knowledge or all reals come under padartha. Padartha means an object which can be thought (ज्ञेयम् । jneya) and named (अभिधेयः । abhidheya). The Vaiseshika system is a pluralistic realism,  a philosophy of identity and difference, which emphasizes that the heart of reality consists on difference.  It is a mere catalogue of the knowables, an enumeration of the diverse reals without any attempt to synthesize them. Originally the Vaiseshika believed in the six categories and the seventh, that of Abhava or negation was added on later.  The Vaiseshika divides all existent reals which are all objects of knowledge into two classes - bhava or being and abhava or non-being. All knowledge necessarily points to an object beyond and independent of it. Nyaya accepts the metaphysics of the Vaiseshika school and the accounts of matter, soul and God are almost the same as those in the Vaiseshika.<ref name=":22" />
+
The Vaiseshika darshana is regarded as conducive to the study of all systems. It deals with the [[Padarthas (पदार्थाः)|Padarthas]] (पदार्थः । categories) and the entire universe is reduced to six or seven padarthas. The word 'padartha' means 'the meaning of a word' or 'the object signified by a word'. All objects of knowledge or all reals come under padartha. Padartha means an object which can be thought (ज्ञेयम् । jneya) and named (अभिधेयः । abhidheya). The Vaiseshika system is a pluralistic realism,  a philosophy of identity and difference, which emphasizes that the heart of reality consists on difference.  It is a mere catalogue of the knowables, an enumeration of the diverse reals without any attempt to synthesize them. Originally the Vaiseshika believed in the six categories and the seventh, that of Abhava or negation was added on later.  The Vaiseshika divides all existent reals which are all objects of knowledge into two classes - bhava or being and abhava or non-being. All knowledge necessarily points to an object beyond and independent of it. Nyaya accepts the metaphysics of the Vaiseshika school and the accounts of matter, soul and God are almost the same as those in the Vaiseshika.<ref name=":22" />
    
As an astika system Nyaya holds that the highest goal is called [[Nihshreyasa (निःश्रेयसम्)|nihsreyasa]] or liberation.<ref name=":1">Adhikary, Jaya. (2003) Ph. D. Thesis Title : ''[http://shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in:8080/jspui/bitstream/10603/137458/4/04_chapter_01.pdf The Nyaya Concepts of Prama Pramana and Pramanya :  A critical study.]'' University of North Bengal</ref> Nyaya-Vaiseshika believes in the doctrine of ''Asatkaryavada'' (असत्कार्यवादः ) which means that the effect does not pre-exist in its cause. The effect is a new beginning, a fresh creation. It is also called Arambhavada (आरम्भवादः) or Paramanukaranavada (परमाणुकरणवादः). Among the Nastika darshanas Hinayana Buddhism, Charvakas, and a group of Mimamsa believes in Asatkaryavada.<ref name=":22" />
 
As an astika system Nyaya holds that the highest goal is called [[Nihshreyasa (निःश्रेयसम्)|nihsreyasa]] or liberation.<ref name=":1">Adhikary, Jaya. (2003) Ph. D. Thesis Title : ''[http://shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in:8080/jspui/bitstream/10603/137458/4/04_chapter_01.pdf The Nyaya Concepts of Prama Pramana and Pramanya :  A critical study.]'' University of North Bengal</ref> Nyaya-Vaiseshika believes in the doctrine of ''Asatkaryavada'' (असत्कार्यवादः ) which means that the effect does not pre-exist in its cause. The effect is a new beginning, a fresh creation. It is also called Arambhavada (आरम्भवादः) or Paramanukaranavada (परमाणुकरणवादः). Among the Nastika darshanas Hinayana Buddhism, Charvakas, and a group of Mimamsa believes in Asatkaryavada.<ref name=":22" />
Line 151: Line 158:  
|Develops logic and epistemology (the theory of knowledge)
 
|Develops logic and epistemology (the theory of knowledge)
 
|-
 
|-
|Recognizes only two Pramanas : pratyaksha (perception) and anumana (inference)
+
|Recognizes only three [[Pramana (प्रमाणम्)|Pramanas]] : pratyaksha (perception) and anumana (inference) and shabda (verbal testimony)
|Recognizes four Pramanas : perception, inference, Upamana (comparison) and shabda (verbal authority).
+
|Recognizes four [[Pramana (प्रमाणम्)|Pramanas]] : perception, inference, Upamana (comparison) and shabda (verbal authority).
 
|}
 
|}
   Line 158: Line 165:  
This system of thought is one of the oldest, but its origin has been a matter with various versions among the scholarly groups. Whatever be its origin, it is considered important next to Vedanta.   
 
This system of thought is one of the oldest, but its origin has been a matter with various versions among the scholarly groups. Whatever be its origin, it is considered important next to Vedanta.   
   −
Samkhya regards both matter and spirit as ultimately real and admits a plurality of Purushas (Self). It traces the whole of the physical universe, with all its variety to a single source called Prkrti. The three gunas or 'cosmic constituents' - Sattva, Rajas and Tamas are in a state of perfect equilibrium Prkrti, until it begins to differentiate itself and the diversity of the things that spring forth (with different proportions of gunas) make up the process of evolution. Evolution here means change of form (parinama). The evolutionary process is periodical and every period of evolution (sristhi) is followed by a period of dissolution (pralaya) when the whole diversity of the universe becomes latent or goes to 'sleep' as it were, in Prkrti.   
+
Samkhya regards both matter and spirit as ultimately real and admits a [[Bahupurushavada (बहुपुरुषवादः)|Plurality of Purushas]] (Self). It traces the whole of the physical universe, with all its variety to a single source called Prkrti. The three gunas or 'cosmic constituents' - Sattva, Rajas and Tamas are in a state of perfect equilibrium Prkrti, until it begins to differentiate itself and the diversity of the things that spring forth (with different proportions of gunas) make up the process of evolution. [[Srshti Siddhanta (सृष्टिसिद्धान्तः)|Evolution]] here means change of form (parinama). The evolutionary process is periodical and every period of evolution (sristhi) is followed by a period of dissolution (pralaya) when the whole diversity of the universe becomes latent or goes to 'sleep' as it were, in Prkrti.   
    
[[Samkhya Darshana (साङ्ख्यदर्शनम्)|Samkhya (साङ्ख्यम्)]] propounds the origin of the 25 principles - Mahat, Ahamkara, the Tanmatras and Purusha.   
 
[[Samkhya Darshana (साङ्ख्यदर्शनम्)|Samkhya (साङ्ख्यम्)]] propounds the origin of the 25 principles - Mahat, Ahamkara, the Tanmatras and Purusha.   
Line 164: Line 171:  
Of this group, the most important are Manas (मनः ।  Mind), Ahamkara (अहंकारः। Egoism) and Buddhi (बुद्धिः ।  intellect),which are together described as Antah-karana (अन्तःकरणम् ।  internal organ). Briefly its chief function is to receive the impressions from outside and respond suitably to them. The whole apparatus, consisting of the Antahkarana and several accessories (sense organs etc) are specific to each individual and together with certain other factors, are supposed to accompany him throughout worldly existence (samsara). This relatively permanent accompaniment of Purusha is known as the sukshma sareera (सूक्ष्मशरीरम् । sutble body). Unlike the physical form 'sthula sarira' (स्थूलशरीरम् । gross body) it does not part from one even at death and is cast off only when freedom is fully achieved.<ref name=":32" />  
 
Of this group, the most important are Manas (मनः ।  Mind), Ahamkara (अहंकारः। Egoism) and Buddhi (बुद्धिः ।  intellect),which are together described as Antah-karana (अन्तःकरणम् ।  internal organ). Briefly its chief function is to receive the impressions from outside and respond suitably to them. The whole apparatus, consisting of the Antahkarana and several accessories (sense organs etc) are specific to each individual and together with certain other factors, are supposed to accompany him throughout worldly existence (samsara). This relatively permanent accompaniment of Purusha is known as the sukshma sareera (सूक्ष्मशरीरम् । sutble body). Unlike the physical form 'sthula sarira' (स्थूलशरीरम् । gross body) it does not part from one even at death and is cast off only when freedom is fully achieved.<ref name=":32" />  
   −
Yoga is intimately allied to Samkhya.  The Bhagavadgita calls them one. Yoga means spiritual action and Samkhya means knowledge. Samkhya is theory and Yoga is practice. Yoga mostly accepts the postulates of Samkhya and shows the practical path by following which one may attain Vivekajnana which alone leads to liberation.  
+
Yoga is intimately allied to Samkhya.  The Bhagavadgita calls them one. Yoga means adhyatmik action and Samkhya means knowledge. Samkhya is theory and Yoga is practice. Yoga mostly accepts the postulates of Samkhya and shows the practical path by following which one may attain Vivekajnana which alone leads to liberation.  
    
Yoga sutras are divided into four parts.   
 
Yoga sutras are divided into four parts.   
Line 175: Line 182:  
Represented primarily by the Sutras of Jaimini, it consists of 12 adhyayas divided into 60 padas (quarters or sections). It considers about a thousand topics so that is by far the biggest of the philosophic sutras and probably oldest among them. Earliest available commentary is by Shavara and this shastra has been explained in two somewhat different ways by Kumarila Bhatta and Prabhakara otherwise known as Guru.  
 
Represented primarily by the Sutras of Jaimini, it consists of 12 adhyayas divided into 60 padas (quarters or sections). It considers about a thousand topics so that is by far the biggest of the philosophic sutras and probably oldest among them. Earliest available commentary is by Shavara and this shastra has been explained in two somewhat different ways by Kumarila Bhatta and Prabhakara otherwise known as Guru.  
   −
Of the seven padarthas formulated in the Nyaya-Vaiseshika theories, the Mimamsa accepts five of them. This philosophy holds that existents like substance and attribute or the particular and the universal are not totally distinct, but distinct while being the same. The relation between them are termed ''Bhedabheda''. Kumarila Bhatta's siddhanta is given briefly here for a general understanding of the Mimamsa school of thought.<ref name=":32" />
+
Of the seven [[Padarthas (पदार्थाः)|padarthas]] formulated in the Nyaya-Vaiseshika theories, the Mimamsa accepts five of them. This philosophy holds that existents like substance and attribute or the particular and the universal are not totally distinct, but distinct while being the same. The relation between them are termed ''Bhedabheda''. Kumarila Bhatta's siddhanta is given briefly here for a general understanding of the Mimamsa school of thought.<ref name=":32" />
   −
'''Kumarila Bhatta Siddhanta :''' The ultimate particles he postulates of the four elements - earth, water, fire, and air - are not indivisible and possess finite magnitude so that they are not strictly atomic at all. Whole and parts are not accordingly absolutely distinct, but distinct while being same. Like the Nyaya-Vaiseshika, this system also postulates 24 qualities but with a few modifications. Mimamsa system accepts six pramanas including perception, inference and verbal testimony apart from the three accepted by Kumarila namely - Comparison (Upamana) Presumption (arthapatti) and Non-apprehension (anupalabdhi). Kumarila primarily advocates that all things are positive from their own standpoint but negative from that of others (Sadasadatmaka).  
+
'''Kumarila Bhatta Siddhanta :''' The ultimate particles he postulates of the four elements - earth, water, fire, and air - are not indivisible and possess finite magnitude so that they are not strictly atomic at all. Whole and parts are not accordingly absolutely distinct, but distinct while being same. Like the Nyaya-Vaiseshika, this system also postulates 24 qualities but with a few modifications. Mimamsa system accepts [[ShadPramanas (षड्प्रमाणाः)|six pramanas]] including perception, inference and verbal testimony apart from the three accepted by Kumarila namely - Comparison (Upamana) Presumption (arthapatti) and Non-apprehension (anupalabdhi). Kumarila primarily advocates that all things are positive from their own standpoint but negative from that of others (Sadasadatmaka).  
    
According to him, who recognizes no God, the Veda is valid, because knowledge and validity is inherent in it. The central features of the Mimamsa view of the Vedas are taken to teach only truth because  
 
According to him, who recognizes no God, the Veda is valid, because knowledge and validity is inherent in it. The central features of the Mimamsa view of the Vedas are taken to teach only truth because  
Line 191: Line 198:  
'''Acceptance of Samavaya relationship'''
 
'''Acceptance of Samavaya relationship'''
 
* Acceptance of Samavaya (the relationship between whole and part) implies that the Prabhakaras regard the substance and attribute, parts and whole, as quite different and do not form an identity in difference (tadatmya) as Kumarila holds.  
 
* Acceptance of Samavaya (the relationship between whole and part) implies that the Prabhakaras regard the substance and attribute, parts and whole, as quite different and do not form an identity in difference (tadatmya) as Kumarila holds.  
'''Explanation of Error'''
+
'''Explanation of Error (Aprama)'''
 
* Kumarila's explanation of error is nearly the same as Nyaya-Vaiseshika. He admits that in error, knowledge partly strays from reality and misrepresents it (anyatha-khyati).
 
* Kumarila's explanation of error is nearly the same as Nyaya-Vaiseshika. He admits that in error, knowledge partly strays from reality and misrepresents it (anyatha-khyati).
   Line 211: Line 218:  
* All the six pramanas are accepted in this philososphy.   
 
* All the six pramanas are accepted in this philososphy.   
 
* Brahman is the sole reality and it appears both as the world and as the individual self (jiva). The former is an illusory manifestation of Brahman, while the later is Brahman itself appearing under the limitations which form part of that illusory universe.  
 
* Brahman is the sole reality and it appears both as the world and as the individual self (jiva). The former is an illusory manifestation of Brahman, while the later is Brahman itself appearing under the limitations which form part of that illusory universe.  
* Creation is effected by transformation and not by evolution, thus agreeing with the philosophy of Samkhya to a certain extent. Brahman is the material cause and source of all. The theory of causation is called Vivartavada, where the variety seen is only an appearance or change of the ultimate source, the Brahman, as the illusory serpent is of the rope.   
+
* Creation is effected by transformation and not by [[Srshti Siddhanta (सृष्टिसिद्धान्तः)|evolution]], thus agreeing with the philosophy of Samkhya to a certain extent. Brahman is the material cause and source of all. The theory of causation is called Vivartavada, where the variety seen is only an appearance or change of the ultimate source, the Brahman, as the illusory serpent is of the rope.   
 
* The means to liberation is neither adherence to moral and religious duty (to cultivate detachment or vairagya) alone nor acquisition of right knowledge alone (jnana) but a combination of both. Thus Vedanta integrates jnana and karma (jnana-karma-samucchaya) for achieving self-perfection and moksha.   
 
* The means to liberation is neither adherence to moral and religious duty (to cultivate detachment or vairagya) alone nor acquisition of right knowledge alone (jnana) but a combination of both. Thus Vedanta integrates jnana and karma (jnana-karma-samucchaya) for achieving self-perfection and moksha.   
 
* When the truth is realized, one attains moksha which is not merely knowing Brahman, but being Brahman. The person who has reached this stage is a jivamukta or a free man, although he may continue to be associated with his several physical accompaniments. When a jivanmukta casts off his physical body at death, he becomes freed in the final sense of the term (videha mukti).   
 
* When the truth is realized, one attains moksha which is not merely knowing Brahman, but being Brahman. The person who has reached this stage is a jivamukta or a free man, although he may continue to be associated with his several physical accompaniments. When a jivanmukta casts off his physical body at death, he becomes freed in the final sense of the term (videha mukti).   
Line 220: Line 227:  
* Ramanuja acknowledges only two categories - substance (dravya) and non-substance (adravya) or attribute. By substance is meant "what undergoes change" or "what has modes (avasthas)" and it is of six kinds, three of which are Prkrti, Jiva and God.  
 
* Ramanuja acknowledges only two categories - substance (dravya) and non-substance (adravya) or attribute. By substance is meant "what undergoes change" or "what has modes (avasthas)" and it is of six kinds, three of which are Prkrti, Jiva and God.  
 
* Prkrti is similar to that conceived in Samkhya, the differences being that according to Ramanuja it is not regarded as independent of spirit and that sattva, rajas and tamas are taken to be its attributes and not its constituents.   
 
* Prkrti is similar to that conceived in Samkhya, the differences being that according to Ramanuja it is not regarded as independent of spirit and that sattva, rajas and tamas are taken to be its attributes and not its constituents.   
* The physical world, in its infinite variety, evolves out of Prkrti under the guidance of God. This theory of causation is termed Satkaryavada, it is the sat itself, or already existing, that is conceived as effect by transformation taking place in the modes (avasthas). The nature of the evolutes and their order of emergence from Prkrti are similar to those of Samkhya.  
+
* The physical world, in its infinite variety, evolves out of Prkrti under the guidance of God. This [[Srshti Siddhanta (सृष्टिसिद्धान्तः)|theory of causation]] is termed Satkaryavada, it is the sat itself, or already existing, that is conceived as effect by transformation taking place in the modes (avasthas). The nature of the evolutes and their order of emergence from Prkrti are similar to those of Samkhya.  
 
* The Jiva is different from God, but not independent of him. It is described as a prakara of God, an accessory to him. The Jivas are of three kinds -  
 
* The Jiva is different from God, but not independent of him. It is described as a prakara of God, an accessory to him. The Jivas are of three kinds -  
 
** those that are never in bondage (Garuda) and have always been free  
 
** those that are never in bondage (Garuda) and have always been free  
Line 239: Line 246:  
* The senses which are instrumental in knowing are reckoned as seven, including manas and sakshin. The conception of Sakshin as an organ of sense (indriya) is a distinctive feature of Dvaita.  
 
* The senses which are instrumental in knowing are reckoned as seven, including manas and sakshin. The conception of Sakshin as an organ of sense (indriya) is a distinctive feature of Dvaita.  
 
* Dvaita is realistic in absolute sense. Existence in space and time is the general criterion of reality.   
 
* Dvaita is realistic in absolute sense. Existence in space and time is the general criterion of reality.   
* God transcends sattva, rajas, and taas which are not qualities of Prkrti (as in Vishishtadvaita) here but are its first products. Attributes of God include infinite power and mercy in addition to being the essence of knowledge and joy. He is apprehensible but not comprehensible.  
+
* God transcends sattva, rajas, and tamas which are not qualities of Prkrti (as in Vishishtadvaita) here but are its first products. Attributes of God include infinite power and mercy in addition to being the essence of knowledge and joy. He is apprehensible but not comprehensible.  
 
* God is not only the creator and destroyer of the whole universe, he also entirely controls each and every one of its aspects.  
 
* God is not only the creator and destroyer of the whole universe, he also entirely controls each and every one of its aspects.  
* Like Vishishtadvaita, here also three pramanas are admitted - perception, inference and verbal testimony.  
+
* Like Vishishtadvaita, here also three [[Pramana (प्रमाणम्)|pramanas]] are admitted - perception, inference and verbal testimony.  
 
* The knowledge of God is essential to release, but the final liberation is achieved through his grace, by the means of unbroken love of God or devotion (bhakti).   
 
* The knowledge of God is essential to release, but the final liberation is achieved through his grace, by the means of unbroken love of God or devotion (bhakti).   
 +
 +
== Unity in Shad Darshanas ==
 +
The knowledge of Six Darshanas may be seen as parts of a comprehensive attempt of a Jivatma to reach the goal of Mokhsa.<ref name=":022">''Sanatana Dharma : An Advanced Textbook of Hindu Religion and Ethics''. (1903) Benares : The Board of Trustees, Central Hindu College</ref>
 +
* In the Nyaya and Vaiseshika, man learns to use his intellectual powers rightly to discern the material constituents of the universe and to detect fallacies.
 +
* Samkhya takes him a step above the material things to understand the constituents of the unseen things (Mahat, Mulaprkriti, Tanmatras, Purusha etc) and the course of evolution of the gross worlds.
 +
* Yoga darshana teaches him to focus on his inner self and Manas to hasten his growth.
 +
* Mimamsa directs him in performing the actions (yajnas, karmas, upasanas) that train him to use the support of invisible world for helping the visible world.
 +
* Vedanta schools teach him to understand the nature of Brahman from the position of physical existence. The paths in which Atman in its perfect stage achieves brahmanhood and finally experiences the Ananda are expounded. 
 +
* In this experience of the Self the Paravidya is attained and the Atma beholds Itself.
    
== Unity in Indian Sadhana ==
 
== Unity in Indian Sadhana ==
 
The aim of studying philosophy is not merely to gratify theoretical curiosity, but also to live the right kind of life, consciously adjusting one's conduct to one's intellectual convictions. In common to all systems, developing discipline consists of two parts namely<ref name=":32" />  
 
The aim of studying philosophy is not merely to gratify theoretical curiosity, but also to live the right kind of life, consciously adjusting one's conduct to one's intellectual convictions. In common to all systems, developing discipline consists of two parts namely<ref name=":32" />  
* for cultivating detachment (vairagya)
+
* cultivation of detachment (vairagya)
* for acquiring knowledge (jnana) of the ultimate reality and transforming it into direct knowledge.
+
* acquision of knowledge (jnana) of the ultimate reality and transforming it into direct knowledge.
 
The former part of the discipline signifies adherence to the duty in the manner taught by Bhagavadgita, with no desire for its worldly fruit but with a view to perfecting character (karma-yoga). Success in this part of training is indicated by the appearance, in the disciple, of the following traits which are described as "fourfold aid" or sadhanachatushtaya to the study of Vedanta. They are  
 
The former part of the discipline signifies adherence to the duty in the manner taught by Bhagavadgita, with no desire for its worldly fruit but with a view to perfecting character (karma-yoga). Success in this part of training is indicated by the appearance, in the disciple, of the following traits which are described as "fourfold aid" or sadhanachatushtaya to the study of Vedanta. They are  
 
# ability to discriminate between the transient and the eternal
 
# ability to discriminate between the transient and the eternal
Line 257: Line 273:  
# '''Manana''' or reflection : as a result of the teaching the disciple comes to know the unity of the individual and ultimate reality
 
# '''Manana''' or reflection : as a result of the teaching the disciple comes to know the unity of the individual and ultimate reality
 
# '''Dhyana''' or meditation : constant dwelling on the truth to transform into direct experience the knowledge acquired by the study of Upanishads
 
# '''Dhyana''' or meditation : constant dwelling on the truth to transform into direct experience the knowledge acquired by the study of Upanishads
Thus we see that all Indian shastras agreed upon the general principles of ethical conduct which must be followed for the attainment of salvation. There are indeed divergences in certain details or technical names, but the means to be adopted for purification are almost same as those advocated by the Yoga system. It is in later times that devotion (भक्तिः ।bhakti) is seen to occupy a more prominent place specially in Vaishnava schools of thought. Thus, although many differences are seen among the various shastras, yet their goal of life, their attitude towards the world and means for the attainment of the goal (साधना । sadhana) fundamentally being the same, advocates a unique unity in the practical sadhana of almost all the Indian philosophical schools of thought. The religious craving has been universal in India and this uniformity of sadhana has therefore secured for India a unity in all her aspirations and strivings.<ref name=":12" />
+
Thus we see that all Indian shastras agreed upon the general principles of ethical conduct which must be followed for the attainment of Moksha. There are indeed divergences in certain details or technical names, but the means to be adopted for purification are almost same as those advocated by the Yoga system. It is in later times that devotion (भक्तिः ।bhakti) is seen to occupy a more prominent place specially in Vaishnava schools of thought. Thus, although many differences are seen among the various shastras, yet their goal of life, their attitude towards the world and means for the attainment of the goal (साधना । sadhana) fundamentally being the same, advocates a unique unity in the practical sadhana of almost all the Indian philosophical schools of thought. The religious craving has been universal in India and this uniformity of sadhana has therefore secured for India a unity in all her aspirations and strivings.<ref name=":12" />
    
==References==
 
==References==
 
<references />
 
<references />
 
[[Category:Darshanas]]
 
[[Category:Darshanas]]
367

edits

Navigation menu