Purushartha (पुरुषार्थ:)

From Dharmawiki
Revision as of 00:10, 15 September 2022 by Fordharma (talk | contribs) (added content)
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Purushartha (Samskrit: पुरुषार्थ:) refers to the four principal categories of pursuits in human life namely, Dharma (धर्मः), Artha (अर्थः), Kama (कामः) and Moksha (मोक्षः). The life of a human being was set in the framework of these four Purusharthas by our ancient seers. The whole body of Bharatiya texts and parampara have all aspects of life and after-life events seen through the lens of the purusharthas. Thus Purushartha drsthi is the most unique of the principles of Sanatana Dharma. While a vast majority of people in the world live a life to fulfil Artha (अर्थः) and Kama (कामः) and a few adhering to Dharma framework, very few pursue the Moksha purushartha.

परिचयः ॥ Introduction

"What is the purpose of my life? What is the aim of my life? What am I born?" - these are a set of common ultimate vocal or silent questions that plague the minds of human beings. All other questions that are raised reduce down to these basic questions.[1]

All human beings are driven by some or the other form of desire to work, to perform Karma, towards the following things as their goals

  1. Basic necessities such as food, clothing and shelter; thus education and livelihood is a prime desire for self sustenance
  2. Providing safety and security for themselves and family. Here the fear and insecurity of the future are addressed.
  3. Supplementing mental and physical wants such as entertainment, investment and so on. Wants can be innumerable.
  4. Morality and ethical goals such as following principles for healthy mental and physical well-being, charity, meditation etc
  5. Perpetuation of family and lineage; work towards in-life and after-life happiness
  6. Duties and responsibilities to family members and society
  7. Attaining happiness, wisdom, knowledge, limitlessness.

These desires are fulfilled when we perform Karma in our everyday lives, such as eating food, working in an office, watching sports, buying groceries, visiting Mandirs or perform pujas, perform danas, perform activities for the sake of family members etc.[1] All these activities ultimately progress with certain limitations within a personal and societal framework primarily with an aim to achieve happiness and freedom and overcome fear, sorrow, ignorance etc. And this well defined framework as per the principles of Sanatana Dharma lead us to the four Purusharthas or life goals, namely Dharma (धर्मः), Artha (अर्थः), Kama (कामः) and Moksha (मोक्षः).[1] Some traditional philosophers like Sankara have tried to interpret these four values as moral value, instrumental value, psychological value and supreme value (paramo, purushartha) respectively.[2]

व्युतपत्तिः ॥ Etymology

The term Purushartha (पुरुषार्थ:) is a compound word consisting of the terms "पुरुषः (purusha)" and "अर्थः (artha)". The term Purusha in the word Purushartha, is derived from the dhatu "पूः" used in the sense of पुरं शरीरं च । one who resides in, enters in पुरि शेते इति। sleeps in the pura (city) or body, i.e., refers to the conscious Jiva who occupies the body is called Purusha (पुरुषः)। The derived meaning of the word Purusha is thus the Jiva or the embodied Atman. Purusha (पुरुषः) in the Rigveda and elsewhere refer to the immanent and transcendental supreme being. In the Bhagavata Purana we see that in the following shlokas

पुरुषत्वे च मां धीराः (Bhag. Pura. 11.7.21)

बह्व्यः सन्ति पुरः सृष्टास्तासां मे पौरुषी प्रिया २२। (Bhag. Pura. 11.7.22)

पुरं पुरुषमात्मवान् । (Bhag. Pura. 3.20.50)

The term Purusha is used mainly to denote "a man", "a person". Thus when mentioned in shastras this term is used to designate not the beings or creatures in general but refers particularly to a human being. In this context the "Purusha" in the term "Purushartha" refers particularly to a human being, specifically to the man and woman.[3] Thus the term purusa is used in two contexts and both are closely interrelated. On the one hand purusa is cosmic in which the entire universe (Brahmanda) is stated and the other is the individual (pinda) in which the human being is connoted. The term ‘purusa’ also means that which moves forward (purati agre gachhati). This meaning is specially relevant to human context because the human being has the potentiality to grow.[2]

The term "artha" in the word Purushartha, has a been explained in the sense of अर्थ्यते प्रार्थ्यते सर्वैः। where it means the "desired fruits" or "desired objects." It can be expanded as पुरुषाणाम् अर्थः। and पुरुषैः अर्थ्थते इति पुरुषार्थः। it means those (results) which are wanted by the Purusha or Purusharthas are those fruits (of efforts) desired by a person.[3]

From these perspectives it can be said in essence that almost everything that we see in this world are the objects that are either to be "known" or "desired" by a Purusha. However, in the view of the shastras, the Vedas or for that matter in the whole body of Samskrit literature it is said that the results of any effort by a man falls into any one of the four categories. Thus Purusharthas are etymologically said to be the four primary desirables or objectives (Chaturvarga) of human pursuits. The ability to fulfill them is solely vested in the human beings and no other being, and hence they are called Purusharthas. After a human being is born, whatever desires (Kama) he has, the activities (Karma) they incite him or her to perform and the results so obtained (karma phala) can be categorized under any of these four goals only. Chaturvarga Phalaprapti is the only logical end for any desire of a human being, as explained clearly in Bhagavata Purana.[3]

पुंसां अमायिनां सम्यक् भजतां भाववर्धनः । श्रेयो दिशत्यभिमतं यद्धर्मादिषु देहिनाम् । ॥ ६० ॥ (Bhag. Pura. 4.8.60)

Hence in this universe the lakshya or goal of all activities of man are Dharma, Artha, Kama and Moksha.

As per Shabdakalpadhruma Purushartha is explained as धर्मार्थकाममोक्षरूपेषु पुरुषस्य इष्टेषु । The desires of a person in the form of Dharma, Artha, Kama and Moksha.

Agni Purana states the four Purusharthas explicitly as धर्मार्थकाममोक्षाश्च पुरुषार्था उदाहृताः । The Purusharthas are exemplified by Dharma, Artha, Kama and Moksha.[4]

Etymology of Chaturvargas

In Amarakosha, we observe that Trivargas and Chaturvargas are defined as follows:

Trivarga:

Adhikari of Chaturvarga

A human being alone is designated to fulfil the chaturvarga, even though the universe is created with beings of all kinds of specialties - all powerful devatas, daityas, danavas etc. Even though they have all the abilities to live and conduct their lives on this earth, they all have one great deficiency. The Bhagavata Purana mentions the following

बुद्धीन्द्रियमनःप्राणान् जनानां असृजत् प्रभुः । मात्रार्थं च भवार्थं च आत्मनेऽकल्पनाय च ॥ २ ॥ (Bhag. Pura. 10.87.2)[5]

Meaning: Paramatma created beings with Buddhi (intellect), Indriyas (sense-organs), Manas (mind), and Prana (vital energy). Through the Pranas, the beings become alive, through the indriyas they hear the shastras, through the Manas they deliberate on the Atma tattva and finally by Manana and by using Buddhi they arrive at what the tattva is pointing to, to attain Atma.[3]

The last of the four intended purposes, the means to fulfil the purpose of being one with Atma, is not fully developed in other beings. Observing this one deficiency, the Srshtikarta created man having the quality to discern and seek Atmavidya. Because of this one exceptional quality - understanding and discerning power of the humans, man became the adhikari to these Chaturvargas which cannot be performed by any other beings. Thus the last for the four goals namely, moksha, cannot be the goal of any other being other than man because Buddhi or intelligence is the instrument functioning at its highest level only in the human.

Uniqueness of the Upadhi of a Human being

It is said that being born as a human is highly desired for only in this Upadhi can the reflection of Paramatma be recognized in the Jiva. In the Aitereya Aranyaka,

पुरुषे त्वेवाऽऽविस्तरामात्मा । स हि प्रज्ञानेन सम्पन्नतमः । विज्ञातं वदति विज्ञातं पश्यति । पशूनामशनापिपासे एवाभिविज्ञानं न विज्ञातं वदन्ति न विज्ञातं पश्यन्ति (Aita. Aran. 2.3.2)[6]

Meaning: In Purusha (manushya sharira) the manifestation of Atman is the highest as compared to other lifeforms. He is the only one endowed with Prajnana or discrimination. Man knows, sees, and speaks along with the understanding that "I am the knower, I am the seer, I am the speaker." An animal (creature) also knows, sees and speaks (utters sounds). But they do not have the understanding of that sense of "I am the knower, I am the seer and I am the speaker." Thus there exists a difference in the cognition level of a human and an animal. It is this extraordinary intelligence of the human which makes him dear to even the deities.[3] Every human being is primarily imperfect but can gradually attain perfection. The Vedic seers and sages were convinced that by constant effort one can attain perfection. And the human being who is the evolute in the cosmic process can be an instrument or agent for the attainment of perfection. Thus the word purushartha not only means goals of human being but also stands for human endeavor.[2] Shri Krishna in Bhagavat Gita clearly states that He is the Buddhi in the body of a man. In the Bhagavata Purana Shri Krishna mentions that in man, having a suitable body, using the the capabilities of Indriyas, Manas etc, an intelligent one can attain the Atman. For this reason, even though the creation has one, two, three, four, multiple and no legged creatures having different kinds of bodies, it is the human being (manushya sharira) which is most loved by the Him, for it is only in this Upadhi he can with focus and concentration reach the unreachable state of attaining that Ishvara which is different from Ahamkara (identification of body with Atman).[3]

पुरुषत्वे च मां धीराः साङ्ख्ययोगविशारदाः। आविस्तरां प्रपश्यन्ति सर्वशक्त्युपबृंहितम् २१।

एकद्वित्रिचतुष्पादो बहुपादस्तथापदः। बह्व्यः सन्ति पुरः सृष्टास्तासां मे पौरुषी प्रिया २२।

अत्र मां मृगयन्त्यद्धा युक्ता हेतुभिरीश्वरम्। गृह्यमाणैर्गुणैर्लिङ्गैरग्राह्यमनुमानतः २३। (Bhag. Pura. 11.7.21-23)[7]

Thus it is the Manushya who is the most intelligent being among all creations in Jagat and capable of Atmasakshatkara and thus chosen as the Adhikari for the four pursuits. This identification of man as not just another animal but is capable of reaching unknown higher realms is the most unique power of man according to Sanatana Dharma.

Trivarga is secondary to Moksha

The Doctrine of Trivarga comprising of Dharma, Artha and Kama is the sum and substance of the Bharatiya philosophy of life, intended to strike a reasonable balance between the interests of the individual and the public interest which means the interests of all other individuals who constitute the society or Nation concerned and includes all humanity. It declares the supremacy of Dharma over Artha (wealth) and Kama (desire for securing material pleasure). It is the invaluable and everlasting solution for all the problems of all human beings for all time to come, irrespective of their belonging or not belonging to any religion.[8]

The propounders of Dharma did appreciate that the fulfillment of desires of human beings was essential but were of the opinion that unless the desires were regulated by law, they would bring about undesirable results. Therefore, all the propounders of Dharma were unanimous that for the existence of an orderly society and the peace and happiness of all, the desires (kama) for material enjoyment, and pleasures (Artha) should always conform to Dharma (Code of Right Conduct) and be never inconsistent with it.[8]

Manu declares

धर्मार्थावुच्यते श्रेयः कामार्थौ धर्म एव च । अर्थ एवेह वा श्रेयस्त्रिवर्ग इति तु स्थितिः । । २.२२४ । । (Manu. Smrt. 2.224) परित्यजेदर्थकामौ यौ स्यातां धर्मवर्जितौ । (Manu. Smrt. 4.176)

Meaning: To achieve welfare and happiness some declare Dharma and Artha are good. Others declare that Artha and Kama are better. Still others declare that Dharma is the best. There are also persons who declare Artha alone secures happiness.[8]

But the correct view is that the aggregate of Dharma, Artha and Kama (Trivarga) secures welfare and happiness. However, the desire (kama) and material wealth (Artha) must be rejected if contrary to Dharma.[8]

In this single verse Manu Smriti has considered the merits of pure materialism (Artha and Kama) and of mere spiritualism (Dharma without Artha) and concluded that it is the combination of Dharma, Artha and Kama which secures welfare and happiness with an overriding principle that desire (kama) and material wealth (artha) should be rejected if they are inconsistent with Dharma and calls this doctrine Trivarga. There can be no better rule or philosophy than Trivarga, for the welfare of the individual and society. It strikes a harmonious balance between the interests of the individual and society. However, while Dharma embraces every type of righteous conduct covering every aspect of life essential for the sustenance and welfare of the individual and society, it also includes those rules which guide and enable the attainment of moksha (eternal bliss)[8]

Everyone wants to be infinitely happy, yet one incessantly gets engaged in the worldly paths forgetting the goal of finding this elusive entity called Atman, which exists, is conscious and limitless. There are two natures of man in terms of his search for Sukha, loosely translated as happiness.[3]

  1. विषयसुखम् (Vishaya Sukha): It is that dukha (includes sadness, pain etc) mixed sukha generated when the karma-, jnana-indriyas come in contact with vishaya (objects in Jagat). It is the pleasure derived from the things around us. After finally getting tired of the unstable nature of such a kind of happiness, there arises in man the thought that these indriyas are limited to the body and I am not that.
  2. आत्मसुखम् Atma Sukha): After fulfilling the vasanas or samskaras from previous lives, in the form of eternal search for vishaya sukha in the outside world, the mind comes to a firm decision that there is something eternal called Atman, which is the original Self of a human and rejoices in this Jnana. Then he is said to be in the state of Atmasukha. It is the ultimate state of a human being only.

To attain and remain in the state of Sukha, it appears that the most important desired purposes of all human beings (sadhya साध्य) are just two namely Kama (desires required to fulfil worldly pleasures) and Moksha and the instruments (sadhanam साधनं) to achieve these two goals are Dharma and Artha. Thus the two pursuits and their two instruments are generally felt necessary by every person. Since Moksha pertains to the domain of Self or Atma it is termed Adhyatma, and the chief instrument to achieve it is Dharma. Artha and Kama are essential instruments for fulfilling the needs in life. Dharma also supports these two needs, the Artha and Kama.[3] Amarakosha defines Trivarga as Dharma, Kama and Artha and along with Moksha as Chaturvarga.

त्रिवर्गो धर्म कामार्थः चतुर्वर्गः समोक्षकः। (Amar. 2.7.57)

While the four purusharthas have their own significance, shastras have given greater importance to Moksha because the Trivargas will eventually lead to Moksha.[3] The trivargas by themselves are faultless when they are used in the way given by the shastras. When the desires and thoughts in the human mind lead the man away from the way the goals have to be pursued, then they become associated with doshas or mala. When dharma is performed with an intent for their worldly results (sakama dharma), artha is used for causes other than charity and personal means (niguhana), when one gets carried away gets excessively attached to desires (moha) - in such cases the trivarga is said to have doshas.

अपध्यानमलो धर्मो मलोऽर्थस्य निगूहनम्। संप्रमोहमलः कामो भूयस्तद्गुणवर्धितः।। (Maha. Shan. Parv. 123.10)

When man pursues dharma without attachments to the results of such actions (nishkama dharma), artha or wealth is sought with an intent to donate and for service (त्यागाय सभृतार्थानाम्), and kama or desires are such that they invoke dharmik way of life - then such trivargas are free from doshas or faults. In such a way when a man follows the goals of life within the frame work of trivarga, they all lead him easily to the fourth paramapurushartha namely Moksha.[3] All the instruments required for achieving Atma sukha by undertaking the path of Paravidya are given to man, such as the laukika Vidyas (Apara Vidya), the Indriyas, Buddhi etc hence man pursuing the "Alaukika अलौकिकम्" path is inherent in the human being to attain the limitless state called as Moksha. Hence Moksa is considered as the supreme value i.e. parama purusartha. It is the ultimate end of human life, because it puts an end to all limitations of human life. Therefore, it has been described as absolute freedom i.e. freedom from the cycle of birth and rebirth.[2]

Purusharthas and their importance

The importance of a particular purusartha varies with the stages of life (ashramas), in which man is in during the course of his life’s journey. In the brahmacarya ashrama, dharma is given utmost importance with minimal-artha and kama essential for bodily maintenance. In the grhastha asrama, kama is of paramount importance, but it must be adequately supported by artha and dharma. In the Brahma Purana it is stated that by balancing the trivargas, a grhastha can reap the benefits in both in this world and beyond (alaukika).

त्रिवर्गसाधने यत्नः कर्तव्यो गृहमेधिना। तत्संसिद्धौ गृहस्थस्य सिद्धिरत्र परत्र च।। २२१.१० ।। (Brah. Pura. 221.10)

In the sannyasa ashrama, moksa along with dharma is the paramapurusartha, artha and kama play a minimal role. In fact one purusartha becomes the foundation of either one or two stages of life (ashrama) of the person concerned. In other words, the scheme of purusarthas ceases to be hierarchical. Each purusartha has equal role for the sustenance of society and welfare of the human beings as long as they are correctly understood and pursued.[8] Besides purusartha as value should not be taken as person specific. No value in true sense can be so. Man being a social animal needs a harmonious and well-balanced life in society. It should strike a balance among the physical, psychic, moral and spiritual aspects. The theory of purusartha aims at providing a guideline that ensures such a harmony for a man in his personal as well as social life. As extolled in Bhagavata Purana, if one pursues only Artha and Kama, then he may as well wash his hands of all purusharthas, because following only these two pursuits a man loses his discrimination and knowledge leading to attaining those forms that are lower than a human.

अर्थेन्द्रियार्थाभिध्यानं सर्वार्थापह्नवो नृणाम् । भ्रंशितो ज्ञानविज्ञानाद् येनाविशति मुख्यताम् ॥ ३३ ॥ न कुर्यात्कर्हिचित्सङ्‌गं तमस्तीव्रं तितीरिषुः । धर्मार्थकाममोक्षाणां यदत्यन्तविघातकम् ॥ ३४ ॥ (Bhag. Pura. 4.22.33-34)[9]

The Trivarga are instruments (sadhanas or upayas) to be used cautiously to achieve a balance in life and the fourth purushartha, Moksha is the end to be attained (sadhya or upeya) using these instruments. It strictly put forth that no thoughts or actions that impede the purusharthas should ever be entertained.[3]

Dharma

Dharma was formulated as the solution to the eternal problems confronting the human race, originating from natural human instincts. ‘Dharma’ as a purusartha provides the principles, or norms by which, one would know whether a given pursuit of artha or kama is worth pursuing. Dharma therefore determines the ethical merit of an action. Thus dharma refers to moral values but not to religious values. In fact dharma is essential for lokasamgraha, in an integrated society in which artha and kama can be pursued meaningfully.[8]

Though a word of wide import, in the present context, Dharma is the standard or norm of an action which is understood in an individual as well as a social context. Its possession is the cause of man's unique nature. It is the characteristic feature that distinguishes man from animals. It represents the moral principle, which gives the human being a sense of worth and meaningfulness. It defines the essential human values such as ethics and morals.[10]

Artha

Artha Paribhasha

Artha is sanctified by Dana

Role of Artha in achieving Dharma

Kama

Kama Paribhasha

Moksha

Moksa is a personalistic or indivudalistic value.[2] Boundlessness or expansion beyond something perceptible is an innate causeless nature governing everyone’s life. Achieving freedom from embodiment is the culminating point of Moksha. All human endeavors are directed, to Moksha, consciously by a few and unconsciously by most people. This solo journey of a Mumukshu, who is consumed by the desire to be unfettered, is unmediated by his own senses, the only leading light being the words of Shruti (heard from the Guru), the Shabdapramana. Once a sadhaka starts the journey into the realms of the mind and consciousness, vrittis of the mind keep him busy within himself.

Discussion

Darwin established the fact of evolution and some of the factors of evolution; and during the next one hundred years after him, biology clarified these still further, and also dealt with the direction of evolution and with the uniqueness of evolution at the human stage. Biology was now bringing to science the concept of the uniqueness of man from a scientific point of view.

References

  1. 1.0 1.1 1.2 What is the Purpose of our Life? By Vishal Agarwal in Bharatiya Vidvat Parishad post.
  2. 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 Nayak, Bibhuti Bhusan. (2004) Ph.D. Thesis: Purusartha in the modern philosophical perspectives. Utkal University (Chapter 1)
  3. 3.00 3.01 3.02 3.03 3.04 3.05 3.06 3.07 3.08 3.09 3.10 Tripathi, Prem Vallabh. (1970) Purushartha Chatushtaya. Varanasi: Rajvidya Granthamala. (Pages 5 -)
  4. Shabdakalpadhruma (See under पुरुषार्थ)
  5. Shrimad Bhagavata Purana (Skanda 10 Adhyaya 87)
  6. Aitareya Aranyaka (Aranyaka 2)
  7. Shrimad Bhagavata Purana (Skanda 11 Adhyaya 7)
  8. 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6 Jois, Rama. DHARMA - The Global Ethic, Bombay: Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan. (Page 18-19)
  9. Shrimad Bhagavata Purana (Skanda 4 Adhyaya 22)
  10. Nayak, Bibhuti Bhusan. (2004) Ph.D. Thesis: Purusartha in the modern philosophical perspectives. Utkal University (Chapter 2)